MyCIMA

Quotas to increase number of women executives in UK ruled out

Sandra Rapacioli's picture

Lord Davies, a former business minister, was asked by Vince Cable, the business secretary, to look for ways to boost gender equality in UK boardrooms. In the UK only 12.5% of directors in FTSE100 companies are women, and there has been no significant improvement in the last 3 years.

An obvious answer would be to set quotas for a minimum percentage of women on boards. It worked in Norway, where in 2005 the government set quotas for women's representation on boards and they now almost 40% of board directors are women, from 6% in 2002. Spain and France have followed suit with quotas and last week Michel Barnier, the European Union's markets commissioner, said he was "open to the idea" of official targets.

Quotas can bring about a marked change...with speed, so the fact that it seems that Lord Davies will completely rule out quotas at this stage seems like a missed opportunity.

Instead, Lord Davies is expected to demand that:

- companies to set their own targets

- diversity should be as much a part of the annual reporting calendar as corporate social responsibility and;

- shareholders should play their part by asking what action the companies they invest in have taken, and also urge the FRC, to apply pressure.

I just hope that S.M.A.R.T KPIs are set against these conditions to measure how successful they are. And if targets are not met, then quotas should be reconsidered.

I also believe that for organisations and shareholders to be pro-active about increasing female representation, and to do this with genuine drive, they need to understand why diversity makes business sense and what’s the real impact on the bottom line of having more women on boards (there’s certainly enough research out there to support this!). I therefore hope that in Lord Davies full report, out later this month, there will be some form of 'education campaign' aimed at businesses and shareholders explaining the benefits of women in leadership!

Sandra

 

On merit not quotas

Board executives should be based on merits not Government imposed quotas…. 

There is an increasing reliance on Government to fix society and install a balance on social diversity. There is a call for Government to set quotas for employers to employ people over 50 to ‘cure’ ageism, quota for 18-25yr to improve employment in that age group, quota on race and then the new buzz word by the tories “The big society”.

 I agree organizations and shareholders should be more proactive in increasing diverse representation but this should be purely based on merit and the will of the shareholders and not imposed by some quota. I also agree that there should be some form of 'education campaign' aimed at businesses and shareholders explaining the benefits of diversity in boardrooms.  

Last thing we need in a time of a slow recovery are people not fit for the job being placed in board rooms to meet quotas… The Government is relying on the private sector to plug the gap left by the cut backs in public sector spending; we need industry leaders that have earned the right to their post that can make the right/best decision for the company – be it male or female….

Women's Networks

Hi Sandra,

I enjoy reading your blogs and find them useful. I am the lead for the women's network within O2 Finance & Professional Services and was wondering if you would be able to do a talk for us?

If you are interested it would be great to hear from you.

Helen

[email address removed by moderator, please use website messaging facilitiy to contact other users]

equality

the reason there is no equality is because men are discriminated against in terms of child care and leave rights. I want to take 9 months paternity leave - I've said this 3 /4 times before.

Until this is the case women at director level will in all likelyhood either 

1. have less experience at a given age post child (especially at the higher levels)

2. be a higher risk of taking maternity leave if they haven't had children yet

so how about not having quotas and campaign for this simple fix...?

In addition now that the more female members are joining CIMA than men, I would be interested ensuring that there is a minimum 45% quota of men joining. Can we start a group representing the rights of men at CIMA.

Diversity

Does anyone have any specific examples of a subcontractor that made an error and the main contractor suffered due to this? Thanks!