MyCIMA

SAR-BOX for the UK

Replies : 4

Look beyond the proposed 50% tax rate announced in the 2009 UK Budget and you will see what might be the first steps towards creating a US-like Sarbanes-Oxley regime in the UK.

The new requirement for the Senior Accounting Officer to certify that a company's internal controls are adequate for the purpose of accurate tax reporting seems to be working against various initiatives to reduce the administrative burden on companies.

The cost of complying will not be insignificant and there is the issue of personal liability for the person signing the certificate.  I'm not sure that we need anything more than the current corporate governance and audit provisions - but what do you think?

 

Cost of Complying

The last thing most companies want is more cost that doesn't drive revenue. Compliance is obviously important but Sarbanes Oxley has created a 'flag day for the consultants', and what good has SarBox done in steering the world or even America away from the financial crisis??

A reaction to the economic crisis

I agree but fear that this is the first sign of a more regulated future following the economic crisis which many feel could have been avoided with more oversight (admittedly of banks rather than all companies).

Senior Accounting Office Tax Controls Certification

Personal certification and hence personal liability for careless or deliberate breaches appears to be an unwelcome measure that also achieves little as I believe even HMR&C recognises that most of the companies affected by the proposed new legislation already have the requisite systems in place, scrutinised annually by auditors. Whilst this represents part of HMR&C’s continuing drive to encourage large companies to recognise and accept their “corporate responsibility” I sense it will just bring unnecessary expense without any real increase in the UK tax take. Just what the current recession needs!! That having been said this sort of attestation is now the way of the world so I expect it to become legislation, irrespective of feedback received during consultation.

Impact on the industry

Here in the US, we have seen a ballooning of the number of "accountants" involved in SOX compliance, and the Big 6/5/4 (or however many there are left now) had a field day recruiting them. However, the wheel is starting to turn, and I can see a day coming when these people are released into the wild, thinking they are accountants, when in fact they are only skilled at box-checking. In the short term, you could see a job boom in the compliance area, but I fear for the long term consequences.