MyCIMA

Does the Walker Review underestimate our contribution?

Peter Simons's picture

The Walker Review  suggests that the non executive directors on banks’ boards should have played a bigger role in corporate governance to provide a counterbalance to management and the bonus culture. But it is not clear that this would have prevented the current crisis.

Realistically, the board will never be close enough to business operations to manage performance.  Management accountants are in a better position and could have an important role to play here - as a report just launched by CIMA shows: Improving decision making – the opportunity to reinvent finance business partners.

CIMA’s purpose is to ensure your employability and enhance your career prospects as a member. The objectives of this and other reports in the ‘Improving decision making’ suite are (a) to inform members about developments in the roles of the finance function so as to help you to future-proof your career and (b) to demonstrate to employers that CIMA members can contribute to improving performance through a wide range of roles: http://www.cimaglobal.com/decisionmaking

This new report considers the finance business partner role in particular. It includes learning from academia and consultants but it derives its credibility from the real insights provided by members. I hope that employers will find that it makes a compelling case for engaging more of us as business partners.

Good CFOs have long acted as both a support and counterweight to the CEO. They help him to shape the future of the organisation but they also ensure that any major decisions are properly considered in the interests of shareholders. This influence can be cascaded through to operational decision making across the business by deploying effective finance business partners.

To properly support decision making in this way seems to require a combination of quantitative accounting skills and more qualitative business skills. Other business people and MBAs will challenge for these roles too.

I see that 85% of those who responded to last week’s CIMAsphere poll ‘Is accounting the right qualification for business partners?’ told us that they think accountants are best placed to fill these roles. 35% of all respondents said that management accounting is the right qualification and 50% agreed but said that business experience is required too. Very few said that CPD is required - but gaining experience could be seen as part of a CPD plan.

I wonder if members find that to become business partners they need real experience in business roles, placements as part of a training program or is just working in a corporate environment enough? And how can CIMA help you?

I would welcome your views.

Does the Walker Review underestimate our contribution?

Sometimes, it's being too close to the business operations that causes problems.

It's true CFOs act as a support & counterweight to the CEO but it's important to remember that company culture and a person's values will always influence decision making. Very few people like rocking the boat. A well qualified and experienced CFO may refrain from saying what he is supposed to say if it's contrary to what the rest of the board thinks. It's safer to leave the company than compromise one's career.

Quantitative accounting skills and more qualitative business skills will sure support decision making. The application, in the real business world, of what we study in the classroom is an ever increasing challenge. There are real pressures to reach targets, to please those on top, to create a name, to dominate, to influence policy makers.

The people who brought the world economy to it's knees did not lack qualitative skills. They were either too close to the situation to see what was coming or too addicted to the game to get out. That's why non-execs would have played their role provided they had higher level information of what was going on.

My view is that one can have all the accounting and managerial skills in the world. If they don't have solid personal values to stand for, they will fall for anything. I am not sure what CIMA can do about that but may be help us explore why we go to work in the first place.

Also, this is not the last economic crisis.

Segregation of Finance

How mant accountants have spent time in front line sales ? How does CIMA treat front line sales as part of the post exam experience to become ACMA ? I would suggest that a period in fron tline selling would be a valuable investment for any ACMA aspiring to senior levels .